Gleeks, prepare to take a trip down memory lane!
In the latest episode ofCarpool Karaoke: The Series,Glee’sLea MicheleandDarren Criss, who played Rachel Berry and Blaine Anderson on the iconic FOX show, reunite to drive around New York City together while singing a duet — or several.

As theFunny Girlstar, 36, belts along to the cover, which was a duet between her andCory Monteith’s character, Criss, 36, supports his pal on air drums and guitar, smiling along as she nails every note.
Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
As Michele’s next part approaches, Criss warns her — “this is you!” — to which she replies “I know!” before resuming the karaoke session, her current voice blending seamlessly with her 2012 self on the track.
“Ah, this is why I had you sing it!” Criss tells his friend at the end of the PEOPLE-exclusive clip.

Before hitting the road with Criss, Micheleshowcased her vocal talentsat the 2023Tony Awardsearlier this month. TheScream Queensactress performed herFunny Girlcharacter Fanny Brice’s iconic song"Don’t Rain on My Parade"— which she also covered onGlee— at the star-studded awards show in N.Y.C.
TheGleealums’ soon-to-be-releasedCarpool Karaokejam seshisn’t their first appearance on the show together. In December of last year, the duoreunited on-screento sing some holiday songs from their own discographies for the musical series.

The talented duo also hangs out outside of theCarpool Karaokecar. Criss and his wife Miashowed up to supportMichele inFunny Girllast fall.
“The amount of times this guy has seen me sing ‘Don’t Rain on My Parade,'” Michele joked alongside an Instagram snapshot of the trio backstage. “I love you @darrencriss and @miavoncriss.”
source: people.com