Photo: Michael Becker/FOX

THE MASKED SINGER: L-R: Robin Thicke, Jenny McCarthy, Ken Jeong and Nicole Scherzinger in the “DC Superheroes Night” episode of THE MASKED SINGER airing Wednesday, March 8

This post contains spoilers from the latest episode ofThe Masked Singer.

Grab your capes forThe Masked Singer’s DC Superheroes Night!

Then hostNick Cannonintroduced the first of three new members of Group 2: Gargoyle.

“From the time I was 6, I pretty much knew I wanted to be a superhero,” Gargoyle said in their clue package, which also featured an “I love L.A.” bumper sticker, hot sauce and a charge card.

Despite Gargoyle’s ambitions, “I was always stick on the sidelines,” they continued. “Until my dad gave me a piece of advice:You’ll never let anyone tell you you can’t do something.”

Gargoyle said they did find success: “I went from the guy they passed on to the guy they passed to.”

Michael Becker/FOX

The Masked Singer

“I’m keen on making waves in the field, but being a part of history is the best bonus I could ask for,” said Gargoyle.

PanelistsKen Jeong,Jenny McCarthy,Robin Thickeand Scherzinger tossed out NFL playersOdell Beckham Jr.and Antonio Gates and Grammy winnerThe Weekndas possibilities for Gargoyle.

Wolf took the stage next.

The Masked Singer

The package included a saxophone, a clock without hands and celebritiesAndy Garcia,Lady Gaga,JAY-ZandAndy Samberg. Wolf also mentioned having been in a movie and won a Grammy.

Wolf coveredThe Doors' “Break On Through (To The Other Side)” before Levi, 42, and Mirren, 77, offered up"Timberlake"as an extra clue.

“J.T. and I collaborated,” Wolf revealed.

Thicke, 45, monologued about how Wolf had to beMichael Bolton, and Scherzinger, 44, agreed. Meanwhile, Jeong, 53, suggested singerRichard Marx.

RELATED VIDEO: Jesse McCartney SaysThe Masked SingerIs the Definition of ‘Not Taking Yourself Seriously’

Squirrel closed out the new arrivals.

“Growing up, I was just your average professional figure skater with Olympic dreams,” Squirrel said in their clue package that also showed Swedish meatballs and a castle. “I wanted to be a child psychologist.”

Squirrel said that, regardless of their childhood dreams, they “landed myself in the psycho city of Hollywood” and “made out withTom Cruise.”

The Masked Singer

“Just like that piece of art, I put time into my work,” Squirrel said. “But it’s all worth it when I get to watch the final product like this clue, hero time.”

Squirrel’s garnered an array of actresses as her guesses:Naomi Watts,Katie Holmes,Michelle Monaghan,Renée Zellweger,Margot RobbieandUma Thurman.

The studio audience voted for their favorite performance of the night and the contestant with the fewest number of votes had to head home. Cannon, 42, announced that on DC Superheroes Night, that would be Wolf.

When Wolf popped off his mask, Thicke and Scherzinger’s guess, “When a Man Loves a Woman” singer Bolton, 70, appeared.

Michael Becker/FOX; Sami Drasin via Getty

THE MASKED SINGER: Wolf in the “DC Superheroes Night” episode of THE MASKED SINGER airing Wednesday, March 8 (8:00-9:01 PM ET/PT) on FOX, Michael Bolton

To figure out who would be the second undercover celebrity to go, Gargoyle and Squirrel faced off in the Battle Royale, with each one putting their spin on 3 Doors Down’s “Kryptonite.” The judges voted for Squirrel to move forward in the competition, but just before Gargoyle revealed their identity, McCarthy rang the Ding Dong Keep It On bell.

“There’s so much more you have to offer,” said McCarthy, 50. “I feel like we just touched the surface.”

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up to date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

The Masked Singerairs Wednesdays at 8 p.m. ET on Fox.

source: people.com